Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 9/04/2025 - Originally published 9/04/2025
Written by SimpleTire, Expertly reviewed by Brett Antosh
All-season tires are engineered to provide reliable performance throughout the year. These versatile tires excel in dry, wet, and light winter conditions, making them a popular choice for road use.
Firestone and Toyo are two popular tire brands, known for their capable range of tires. These brands offer a dependable range of all-season tires for confident driving year-round. The all-season tires from both brands feature advanced tread designs to provide reliable traction on paved roads. The Firestone All Season and the Toyo Extensa A/S II are their two dependable all-season tires offered with similar capabilities. Both of these tires are meant for use on passenger cars, CUVs, SUVs, and minivans. They both offer great performance, but one has to be better than the other, right? Let’s compare Firestone All Season vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires using SimpleScore to show where each tire excels and which one might be right for you.
Firestone All Season tires
The Firestone All Season is an all-season tire that's designed for use on coupes, sedans, CUVs, and minivans, and offers drivers strong traction in dry, wet, and light winter weather. The tire is backed by a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. When it comes to features, the All Season is equipped with wide lateral grooves, a special shoulder design, stiff tread blocks, and an optimized tread design. It is also optimized for low rolling resistance for increased fuel efficiency and sports a wider, flat profile for even wear. This tire earns a SimpleScore of 8.3 in handling, an 8.4 in traction, and an 8.7 in longevity. Overall, it earns an average SimpleScore of 8.4, making it a great all-season tire.
Get Firestone All Season tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Toyo Extensa A/S II tires
If you are looking for an alternate tire brand that is equally efficient in gripping the roads and delivering great performance all year round, look at the Toyo Extensa A/S II, which is an all-season tire that's designed for use on CUVs, SUVs, minivans, passenger cars, and light trucks, and offers drivers better wet and dry traction, increased fuel efficiency, good braking performance, and an up to 75,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty for T and H rated sizes, and 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty for V rated size. You also get Toyo's 500-Mile or 45-Day Trial, and Mileage Warranty (restrictions and limitations apply).
The Extensa A/S II includes an innovative design that gives drivers a quiet, comfortable ride, plus an optimized footprint that allows for even wear to extend the tire's tread life. This tire boasts a solid SimpleScore of 8.8.
Get Toyo Extensa A/S II tires at the best deals for your vehicle here
Firestone All Season vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on traction
In the case of all-season tires, traction plays an important role as it relates to maintaining grip on dry, wet, and light snow-covered roads. Both the All Season and the Extensa A/S II tires are designed to provide solid grip across various weather conditions. These tires aim to strike a balance between performance year-round. Let’s take a look at their traction abilities.
When comparing both tires, you will see that the Firestone All Season is designed with symmetrical tread along with wide grooves that funnel water out of the tread to reduce the risk of hydroplaning on wet roads. The All-Season also features dense siping that bites into the road for extra grip year-round. This helps this tire achieve an average traction SimpleScore of 8.4, which is great when it comes to performance.
The Toyo Extensa A/S II, on the other hand, has a score of 8.6 out of 10 in traction. Thanks to a special symmetrical tread design that enhances grip and four wide grooves within its tread that force water out of the contact patch for added hydroplaning resistance. With considerable traction year-round, the Extensa A/S II turns out to be a dependable choice. Even in light winter conditions, the Toyo Extensa A/S II’s traction is better than its competitor.
With a slightly higher SimpleScore in traction, the Extensa A/S II takes the lead!
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Extensa A/S II
Firestone All Season vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on handling
Handling is another key attribute that relates to driving dynamics. It is highly dependent on different tread elements, in addition to the tire’s overall design. When we analyzed both tires, we found that one of the tires was slightly ahead of the other with a better SimpleScore and offered better controllability, lane-changing ability, cornering, and braking efficiency.
The Firestone All Seasons earns a solid 8.3 SimpleScore for handling, which is largely driven by the tire’s wide circumferential grooves to maintain stability in wet and slick conditions and other features like robust construction, strong shoulders, solid ribs, tread sipes, and sturdy rubber compound.
On the flip side, the Toyo Extensa A/S II comes with a SimpleScore of 8.6. It features an innovative design that offers quiet and comfortable rides, a flat contact patch for improved stability, and detailed sipes for improved braking performance and ride control. Yet again, the Extensa A/S II takes the lead with a slightly higher SimpleScore rating.
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Extensa A/S II
Firestone All Season vs Toyo Extensa A/S II tires on longevity
Traction and handling play a crucial role in a tire’s life, and so does longevity. The longevity of a tire depends on several factors, including the quality of the tire, driving habits, road conditions, and maintenance. Based on SimpleScore, the gap in the longevity scores of both tires was maximum.
Starting with the Firestone All Season, the tire offers a great SimpleScore of 8.7 out of 10 on the longevity front. The tire’s tough, rugged rubber compound and reinforced construction work together to promote a longer tread life. Additionally, the tire’s optimized design and tied shoulders put more rubber on the road for longer and even wear.
Conversely, the Extensa A/S II’s excellent 9.4 SimpleScore in longevity shows that it excels its competition in this area. The Toyo Extensa A/S II also features reinforced construction, and its innovative tread design is optimized for even wear to extend the tire's tread life.
When it comes to tread life warranty, the Firestone All Season comes with a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, whereas the Extensa A/S II surpasses with an up to 75,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
In longevity, the Extensa A/S II is a clear winner!
ADVANTAGE: Toyo Extensa A/S II
When to use each
All-season tires are meant to be used year-round, and they offer convenience by using a single set of tires, without any seasonal swaps. They tend to have a longer lifespan compared to tires designed specifically for certain weather conditions, such as winter or summer tires. This is because they are constructed with a tread compound that balances handling and performance across different seasons.
If you live in areas that receive heavy snowfall or in a region that witnesses sub-freezing temperatures, neither the Firestone All Season nor the Toyo Extensa A/S II will provide optimal performance, as they are not built for use in extreme winter weather conditions. Their usage is limited to areas with light snowfall. What will work best in extreme winter conditions is a set of winter tires as they deliver improved traction and handling performance on thick layers of ice and snow.
Which one should you choose?
So, which all-season tire is the right option for you? When looking at SimpleScore, the Toyo Extensa A/S II is better than the Firestone All Season as it scores an 8.8 overall rating, compared to the latter’s 8.4 overall score. As noted above, there are key differences between the two tires, and these need to be weighed against each other to determine what’s best for you.
Finally (and maybe, most importantly), the pricing of these two tires varies as Firestone All Season tires cost at least $104.99 per tire while Toyo Extensa A/S II tires cost at least $87.66 per tire. That means a set of four Firestone All Season tires will cost you at least $419.96 for a set of four, while a set of four Toyo Extensa A/S II tires will cost you at least $350.64.
Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Firestone All Season if you:
- Drive a CUV, SUV, or minivan like the Mazda CX-50, Toyota RAV4, or Honda Odyssey
- Are comfortable paying more to own reliable all-season tires
Conversely, you should choose the Toyo Extensa A/S II if you:
- Drive a Honda Civic, Nissan Cube or a Fiat 500
- Need long-lasting tires
- Need tires that are better in handling
- Need tires that are better in traction
- Need more affordable but better-performing all-season tires
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.